Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Are those cheques British?

Paul Bew writing in Parliamentary Brief:
For all their vote-gaining powers the main unionist and republican leaders are intellectually exhausted and there is no new talent coming through.

They are united only by a common desire to despoil the UK Treasury. Dean Swift famously once said ‘Burn everything English except their coals’. The slogan was adopted by the economic nationalist Irish government of the 1930s. Now there is a new slogan: ‘Burn everything British except the cheques from the Treasury’.
A bit harsh perhaps; after all, the superficialities of British "cultural" identity are still important for many of the unionist leaders but apart from that - on a day to day policy basis, what differentiates their regionalist outlook from that of the Scottish and Welsh nationalists?
The one party which sought to challenge this comfortable regional assumption failed to make any breakthrough; the Ulster Unionists in alliance with the Conservatives (UCUNF) failed to win a single parliamentary seat, though some candidates performed decently.
Use of the collective "party" there is misleading. There wasn't/isn't any sense of cohesive and united will within the UUP to truly develop the type of politics that our fellow-citizens in the rest of the UK take for granted - hence the logic, in my mind, of realignment within pro-Union politics; many within the party share not only the DUP's view of Northern Ireland's role within the wider British nation but also their cultural and social conservatism; what then is the point of two separate candidates continuing to stand under two competing banners whilst sharing almost identical versions of Unionism?
The relationship between the UK and Northern Ireland therefore remains pretty much where it was. The local media claims that it wants a modernised system, but reacted violently to the only modernising initiative on offer this time around. The failure to deepen the political relationship between London and Belfast finds its parallel in Dublin’s loss of interest in Northern Ireland as the Republic fights to save its viability as an independent state in the current crisis.
A justified dig at the local political media. Heaven knows the attempt to get that "modernising initiative" up and running was strewn with mistakes and miscalculations, but the honest NI hack will also admit that "normalised" or "modernised" politics here is the very last thing he needs for his career and so their instinctive opposition to the project right from the beginning.

Not all bad news though:
The good news for the new British Prime minister is that Northern Ireland as a time-consuming issue is all but over. Whitehall civil servants calculated that Tony Blair spent 40 per cent of his time on it in his first couple of years in office. It will be very surprising if the new man has to spend more than four per cent of his time on the same subject.
It would be nice with that stability in place now to think that our politicians would start spending more energy on the bigger UK picture...

5 comments:

Lee said...

For such an obviously intelligent man, Bew's inability to learn from electoral failure always surprises me.

O'Neill said...

Which of his points do you disagree with specifically?

Anonymous said...

I don't get this obsession with "Unionism" - one day the union will end.

Lee said...

Pretty much all of them to be perfectly honest. He ends up characterising the world as he wants it to be rather than as it actually is as some intellectual consolation of electoral defeat.

O'Neill said...

Pretty much all of them to be perfectly honest.

As far as I can see his post had these main points:

1. NI is no longer a time-consuming issue for the UK government
2."The general election strengthened the stability of the devolved institutions considerably".
3. The DUP, "wounded in the European election, has regained its electoral hegemony within the Unionist community".
4."There is little that threatens the existence of the power-sharing deal; even the long lingering mess of educational policy should sort itself out in time."
5 "For all their vote-gaining powers the main unionist and republican leaders are intellectually exhausted and there is no new talent coming through."
6.Nationalism and the DUP "are united only by a common desire to despoil the UK Treasury"
7 "The one party which sought to challenge this comfortable regional assumption failed to make any breakthrough"
8.The relationship between the UK and Northern Ireland remains pretty as it was.
9.The local political media have an instinctively hostile attitude to anything which potentially limits their own importance in the future.

I imagine you'd only disagree with me on point 6 and 9 (and poss 5). All 3 are obviously subjective (although I'd love to hear someone trying to disprove pt.5). He's not using them as excuse for the election defeat though is he?

Apart from that I think he's describing perfectly the world as it stands at the minute.