Let's just say The Toytown parliament does collapse- what would be the real impact on peoples' lives in Northern Ireland?
Events in the recent past in two EU countries, Belgium and the Czech Republic, have proven that you don’t actually need a functioning government for the country to likewise function....buses will still run, bins will still be collected, taxes will still be paid and squandered. And we presently certainly do not have a "functioning government" of any description in Northern Ireland; our own Toytown Parliament in Northern Ireland has, to all intents and purposes, ceased to function and "govern" our small corner of the UK since the end of May. And, despite the "impasse", "crisis",*yawn* setbacks and more "intransigence" than you could shake a stick at...life still potters along. Can anyone honestly say that "governance" of Northern Ireland is any worse now, than it was in April or May? Of course not, and apart from, perhaps, the area of education (although even there, keeping Ruane’s hands tied has meant things haven’t, at least, got any worse) the impasse/crisis/setbacks/intransigence hasn’t caused any meaningful damage whatsoever to Northern Ireland.
The first truth is that the core problem between the DUP and Sinn Fein, the area of policing and justice, will not be improved by devolving it locally- any policing system needs impartiality and professionalism to operate efficiently and do you really expect our local heroes to deliver that?
The second truth is we don’t need Stormont for Northern Ireland to function in a much better way than it is at the minute; the truth is that we (the UK taxpayers) are paying for an expensive talking-shop, full of self-important and over-promoted parish-pump, communal spokesmen (I won’t dignify them with the title “politicians”).
Now, of course, there would be consequences of mothballing Peter, Marty & Co.- “Dump devolution and we’ll get lumbered with an Irish Language Act” appears to be the greatest threat being employed at the minute by both the Dupes and the Republicans. If that is indeed the case, then, yes, well, whatever, go for it. It can be argued that minority language provision in Northern Ireland lags behind the rest of the United Kingdom and if we wish to be regarded as a fully-paid up part of the UK, then the question deserves to be at least debated in a mature and detached manner- at Westminster.
So, really, for me, not that much of a threat then.
Let's get back to Westminster.
4 comments:
It'll be intriguing to see what happens in the next few weeks. Has the relationship (if there ever was one) irrevocably broken down between the axes of power within the Executive? The civil service appears to be keeping the engine ticking over, as was most likely always the case at any rate.
We will, of course, be threatened with consequences if the Executive collapses; or ,at least, the politicians will be anyway.
Have Sinn Fein got much to lose if the Executive fell?
Tim
>>It can be argued that minority language provision in Northern Ireland lags behind the rest of the United Kingdom<<
Ach I'm disappointed with you O'neil. There should be a language act purely on the ground that it is a valued part of the heritage of Ireland. Spare us the nonsense about keeping up with the Finchley's.
I agree that the farce that is Stormont should cease. Joint authority, with equal payments should free up some more money for the UK to pay for foreign wars. leading eventually to a plebiscite in which a smooth transfer to full authority of the Irish Republic..
There should be a language act purely on the ground that it is a valued part of the heritage of Ireland.
..and the British Isles. I'd welcome a proper debate on the matter arguing dispassionatley the pros and cons of an ILA, we're not going to get tht at Stormont.
Spare us the nonsense about keeping up with the Finchley's.
I lived for a very short-time in Finchley and even at thte time of Thatcher's comment it was a truly multi-cultural area with more than one language spoken and colour seen. We could aim for worst places to keep up with.
I agree that the farce that is Stormont should cease.
Good!
Joint authority, with equal payments should free up some more money for the UK to pay for foreign wars. leading eventually to a plebiscite in which a smooth transfer to full authority of the Irish Republic..
You really need to speak to the ROI's government and taxpayers first before you make such kind offers on their behalf..there may be more resistance than you'd think.
As a fellow former Finchley resident I agree
Some stats of interest:
2001 Census Demographics
Total 2001 Population: 106378
Born outside UK: 35.9%
White: 74.2%
Black: 5.2%
Asian: 12.3%
Mixed: 3.2%
Other: 5.1%
Christian: 40%
Hindu: 6.8%
Jewish: 19.6%
Muslim: 6%
Post a Comment